March 30, 2018
Two Compelling Characters: Leni in The Great Alone (Fiction) and Tara in Educated (Nonfiction)
Today I’m highlighting two most compelling characters: Leni from The Great Alone (fiction) and Tara from Educated: A Memoir (nonfiction). Leni and Tara share some similar struggles and challenges. The two stories reminded me at times of The Glass Castle (charismatic yet unpredictable fathers, unstable homes, neglect, poverty) and Hillbilly Elegy (chaotic family life, nurturing grandparents)….a fascinating book club discussion could be centered around discussing the connections between these books and characters.
I’d love to hear which characters you read about this month that were the most memorable for you.
Meet Leni and Tara:
For me, memorable characters who grow and change despite the obstacles make all the difference in a good story. Both Leni and Tara are my choices for this month’s most compelling characters because they share some experiences and traits that make them memorable. Both endure emotional and physical abuse (not sexual), yet despite difficult childhoods, they each rise above their circumstances. Surprisingly, they continue to love and show devotion for their parents (this struck me in The Glass Castle, as well). Leni and Tara share a drive to pursue an education and a desire to belong. In addition, they are determined, persistent, courageous, loyal, clever, and brave. Each girl feels threatened (one by her father and the other by her brother) and fears for her safety. While Leni receives support from her small village community, Tara receives support from one brother, a BYU counselor, and some professors. Each girl is memorable in her grit, her ability to survive, and her drive to strive for something better in her life.
Tara’s words after dance class: “The other girls rarely spoke to me, but I loved being there with them. I loved the sensation of conformity. Learning to dance felt like learning to belong.”
Tara’s words about her abusive brother: “Shawn had more power over me than I could possibly have imagined. He had defined me to myself, and there’s no greater power than that.”
Brief Synopsis and Review of The Stories:
These memorable characters allow me to rate both stories 4 Stars and to recommend these reads to others.
***Trigger warning: domestic abuse
The Great Alone is the story of a dysfunctional family that eventually moves to the harsh wilderness of Alaska to make a fresh start. In this page-turner by Kristin Hannah (author of The Nightingale), thirteen-year-old Leni watches her gentle and artistic mother struggle to live a happy and secure life with her father, a Vietnam War vet, who suffers from PTSD. A survivalist, her father becomes more paranoid and controlling as the story progresses. ***trigger warnings for emotional and physical abuse*** Leni, struggling to stay in school and walking on eggshells around her father, is also concerned about her mother and about their general well-being as the dark winter and isolation of the Alaskan wilderness cause her father’s symptoms to worsen. The first part of the story is slower-paced and devoted to establishing a sense of place, character development, and a slow build-up of the problem. The last part of the story unfolds at a rapid pace and there are attempts to escape and confrontations. Some have commented that the ending is tied together easily, quickly, and conveniently. This didn’t bother me too much because rapid emotional plot twists are Kristin Hannah’s style and part of me was eager and relieved to have closure to Leni’s story. If you’re looking for an engaging page-turner with an Alaskan wilderness setting, this is a good selection to meet that criterion. However, The Nightingale remains my favorite work by Kristin Hannah. My Rating for The Great Alone: 4 Stars. (March Amazon Rating 4.6 Stars)
The Great Alone Information Here
Educated is a memoir by Tara Westover. Tara grew up as one of seven children in a Mormon family making their home in Idaho. Both parents are devout Mormons; however, her father is an extremist, survivalist, and he isolates the family while stockpiling supplies, avoiding the government, and planning for worst-case scenarios. While Tara’s soft-spoken mother makes healing herbs and ointments and practices midwifery, her charismatic father makes a living extracting and selling scrap from his junkyard. To avoid the government, the children do not have birth certificates, are not taken to the doctor, and most of them are homeschooled, although according to Tara’s account, Mom’s interest for homeschooling waned with the younger ones and to complicate the situation, Dad always needed help in the junkyard. Tara wished she could go to school, and I didn’t receive the impression that her parents would have kept her from school, it’s that she suffered from not having the right clothes, feelings of not belonging, and often felt pressured to help her father in the junkyard. Over the years she experiences mental and physical abuse from one of her brothers, becomes more dissatisfied with her chaotic home life, and her desire for education grows. With the encouragement of a brother, she decides to study independently for the ACT and make application to BYU. Thus begins her educational journey, her path of self-realization, healing, and ultimate separation from her family. Tara’s first classroom experience was at age 17. Readers will thoroughly understand and empathize with how difficult and emotional it was for her to take these steps as she’s a loyal girl who feels a great duty to her family. Tara’s understanding of “education “ is that with it, one can gain one’s own perspective on life. Here is Tara’s interview with CNN. If you’re looking for a compelling memoir similar to The Glass Castle, you might enjoy this selection. ***Trigger Warning: poverty, neglect, physical and emotional abuse. My Rating for Educated: 4 Stars. (March Amazon Rating: 4.7 Stars).
I’d love to hear all about the most memorable character(s) from your March reading!
Have you read Educated or The Great Alone or are they on your TBR?
Happy Reading Bookworms!
“Ah, how good it is to be among people who are reading.”
~Rainer Maria Rilke
“I love the world of words, where life and literature connect.”
~Denise J Hughes
“Reading good books ruins you for enjoying bad ones.”
~Guernsey Literary and Potato Peel Pie Society
“I read because books are a form of transportation, of teaching, and of connection!
Books take us to places we’ve never been, they teach us about our world, and they help us to understand human experience.”
~Madeleine Riley, Top Shelf Text
I have several books on hold at the library (I’m #27 for The Force of Nature so that will be a while) and I’m waiting for kindle prices to fall on some new releases……consequently…….next Friday I’ll read and review a book already on my shelf, Eden by Jeanne McWilliams Blasberg (and check it off my winter TBR list).
What are you reading this week?
Reading Podcasts I Love
Modern Mrs. Darcy: What Should I Read Next
Read-Aloud Revival (focus on children’s literature)
Reading Women (reviews of books written by women about women)
Reading Recommendation For Middle-Grade Girls Who Love Science!
Finding Wonders: Three Girls Who Changed Science by Jeannine Atkins is a beautifully and creatively written middle-grade story exploring the lives of 3 girls who are curious, love questions and the world around them, and are persistent in pursuing their love of science and scientific inquiries. Each woman makes important scientific contributions, and I loved reading about them and the context of their lives. I’m not sure middle-grade students will read slowly enough to appreciate the beautiful prose and nuance/subtlety of language, so it might be a good “read together” book.
The author ensures that the girls exhibit some modern feminist thoughts that struck me as the author’s agenda rather than something girls in that era would usually think. However, these thoughts might provoke good conversation starters. For example: “But she hates embroidery, its worth measured by the smallness of stitches. A needle woman trains her eyes to stay cast down while hiding knots and boredom, committing herself to the circumference of a lap.”
An interesting extension read for adults might be The Gilded Years by Karin Tanabe, a fictionalized biography of the first African-American woman (passing as white) to attend Vassar (the same college where Maria Mitchell in Finding Wonders was a professor).
Finding Wonders is an interesting, creative, and worthwhile read. It makes me eager to read all the untold stories! My Rating: 4 Stars
Finding Wonders Information Here
Let’s Get Social!
Thank you for visiting and reading today! I’d be honored and thrilled if you choose to enjoy and follow along (see subscribe or follow option), promote, and/or share my blog. Every share helps us grow.
Find me at:
***Blogs posts may contain affiliate links. This means that at no extra cost to you, I can earn a small percentage of your purchase price.
Unless explicitly stated that they are free, all books that I review have been purchased by me or borrowed from the library.
Book Cover and author photos are credited to Amazon or an author’s (or publisher’s) website.
My most memorable character in March was Franka Gerber from “White Rose Black Forest” by Eoin Dempsey. I enjoyed Franka’s transformation from her youthful ignorance and membership in the League of German Girls and Hitler Youth to her realization of the horrors of a Nazi-controlled society and life as a dissident.
“No one wanted to be left behind, and Franka found herself swept up in the tidal wave of enthusiasm the new dawn of the Aryan people. She didn’t know any other races, but the National Socialists insisted that she and her friends were blood born into a master race, and that they were superior to all others. It felt good. She felt part of something important. So she joined (The League of German Girls), despite the protestations of her parents, who seemed wary of the Nazi Party at almost every level.”
This character was one of the most thoroughly developed I have seen in a work of fiction in a long while. Franka’s transformation did not come easily, and she was exposed to a great deal of heartache. In Ch1 she has reached the point of suicide, but the appearance of an injured stranger changes the course of her life. The book is half over before we see the culmination of their meeting. With the well-told story of Franka’s life being shown up to this point, you become thoroughly engrossed in what may be her final opportunity to redeem her life and bring meaning to the tragedies she has endured, as well as help destroy Hitler and Nazi Germany.
Wow! Thanks for sharing! I’m putting this at the top of my TBR 👍 It sounds like exactly the type of book I enjoy! 😄
[…] this summer and show up on your local Target shelf. (By the way, I didn’t put the popular The Great Alone on my summer list because I’ve already read and reviewed it here. I recommend it for your […]
[…] Educated by Tara Westover […]
[…] Do the events of the story move the story forward at a nice pace? Or are there places where the story drags? At the story’s end, are you left with unanswered questions and disappointed with dangling story lines? Is the story predictable? (this is something that readers tend to either like or dislike) Does it bother you if you are able to consistently guess what is going to happen before it happens? Honestly, predictability takes a bit of the enjoyment out of the story for me and I usually give those stories three stars. Is the story engaging? Is it a page turner? Is it a happily ever after (HEA)? Is it unputdownable? Is the story character driven or plot driven? An example of character driven is A Gentleman in Moscow, and an example of plot driven is The Great Alone. […]
[…] It’s inspiring for mature middle grade girls (and adults) to read fictionalized biographies of three real women scientists and their contributions. Review (scroll down page) […]
[…] The Great Alone by Kristin Hannah 4 Stars […]
[…] Glass Castle (NF Memoir) by Jeanette Walls (movie) and Educated (NF Memoir) by Tara Westover and The Great Alone (Fiction) by Kristin Hannah (for readers who want […]
[…] the Odds” trope. A few fiction and nonfiction examples include The Glass Castle, Educated, In Pieces, Amal Unbound, Hillbilly Elegy, The Book Woman of Troublesome Creek, On the Come […]
[…] Tara ( Educated), J.D. Vance ( Hillbilly Elegy), Jeannette (The Glass Castle), Bryan (Just Mercy), Josef, Isabel, […]
[…] It’s inspiring for mature middle-grade girls (and adults) to read fictionalized childhood biographies of three real women scientists and their contributions. Review (scroll down the page) […]
[…] My Summary: The Great Alone is a story about a dysfunctional family that eventually moves to the harsh wilderness of Alaska to make a fresh start. In this page turner by Kristin Hannah (author of the Nightingale), thirteen-year-old Leni watches her gentle and artistic mother struggle to live a happy and secure life with her father, a Vietnam War vet, who suffers from PTSD. A survivalist, her father becomes more paranoid and controlling as the story progresses. ***trigger warnings for emotional and physical abuse*** Leni, struggling to stay in school and walking on egg shells around her father, is also concerned about her mother and about their general well-being as the dark winter and isolation of the Alaskan wilderness cause her father’s symptoms to worsen. The first part of the story is slower paced and devoted to establishing a sense of place, character development, and a slow build up of the problem. The last part of the story unfolds at a rapid pace and there are attempts to escape and confrontations. Some have commented that the ending is tied together easily, quickly, and conveniently. This didn’t bother me too much because rapid emotional plot twists are Kristin Hannah’s style and part of me was eager and relieved to have closure to Leni’s story. If you’re looking for an engaging page turner with an Alaskan wilderness setting, this is a good selection to meet that criteria. My Review. […]
[…] Two girls desperate for an education: The Girl With the Louding Voice by Abi Dare and Educated by Tara Westover […]
[…] Continue here for my review of the Great Alone and Educated … […]
[…] (My review of Educated here) […]
[…] My most recent experience involves The Four Winds by Kristin Hannah. I am familiar with her work (The Great Alone, The Nightingale, and The Winter Garden), but I know that she can make me ugly cry (especially her […]
I have a few memorable characters:
*The sisters in the Nightingale (by Kristin Hannah)
*Melody in Out of My Mind (by Sharon Draper); Melody is not like most people. She cannot walk or talk, but she has a photographic memory; she can remember every detail of everything she has ever experienced. She is smarter than most of the adults who try to diagnose her and smarter than her classmates in her integrated classroom – the very same classmates who dismiss her as mentally challenged because she cannot tell them otherwise. But Melody refuses to be defined by cerebral palsy. And she’s determined to let everyone know it – somehow.
*Petey in the book Petey
Ahhhhh….I love memorable characters! Thanks for mentioning these! The sisters in Nightingale are memorable indeed!
[…] Broken by Jewel or The Glass Castle by Jeanette Walls or Educated by Tara Westover paired withThe Choice by Edith Eva Eger or Unbroken by Lauren […]
[…] (My review of Educated here) […]
[…] Educated: A Memoir by Tara Westover, recommended by the Reading Ladies Book Club […]
[…] Educated by Tara Westover […]
[…] While reading, I remembered reading a Middle-Grade book about the childhoods of three female scientists (one was Maria Mitchell), Finding Wonders: Three Girls Who Changed Science by Jeannine Atkins (scroll down the page for the re… […]